Fantasy Baseball 2014 Player Rankings by Position

February 26 6:21pm
Nick Sharp
by Nicholas Sharp

About the FanDuel MLB 2014 Preview Series

We’ve long professed our love for one day fantasy sports, and our stance on fantasy baseball is no different. Instead of playing in just one season-long fantasy baseball league, FanDuel offers the chance to play in a new league every single day of the 2014 fantasy baseball season– for real money! We’ll be paying out up to $1,000,000 per day during the 2014 fantasy baseball season (yea, that’s a lot of zeros) and you can play for as much or as little as you like from $1 to $10,000. Click here to deposit on-site and use the promo code MLBPREVIEW14. We’ll match 100% of your deposit up to $200…That’s free money, people!

With all that being said, we know a lot of you will sign-up for season-long leagues and actually care for the first 3-4 weeks. We’ve decided to help all of you out by putting together the FanDuel MLB 2014 Preview Series. We surveyed 32 of the best MLB bloggers out there and compiled the information into 8 parts to give you the finest 2014 fantasy baseball preview the internet can provide.

Without further ado, let’s get into the first part of our series: fantasy baseball 2014 player rankings by position.

Want to share this image on your site? Go for it! Scroll to the bottom of this article for the embed code.

Fantasy Baseball 2014 Rankings by Position

BREAKDOWN

Catcher Rankings

Experienced fantasy baseball connoisseurs know that the catcher position is rarely full of big names and locking up the top guys is tough to do. Buster Posey convincingly led the pack as the favorite catcher. The 2012 NL MVP got off to fast start in 2013, but fell off considerably after the All-Star break. If Posey can sustain his production year-long, he’ll likely finish far and away as the top-producing catcher in Major League Baseball.

Yadier Molina’s durability and production make him a solid second choice, while Joe Mauer is a bit of a wild card going into 2014 with his reported move to 1B. Make sure to keep an eye on his position eligibility when thinking about adding Mauer to your squad.

 

1B Rankings

We’ve seen a bit of a changing in the guards at 1B over the past few fantasy baseball seasons. Arizona’s Paul Goldschmidt blossomed into a star last season and fittingly led the way in our voting. Goldy offers five-category production like few other first baseman can match, including a surprising 15 stolen bases in 2013.

Behind Goldschmidt, voting was essentially a toss up between Chris Davis and Joey Votto. If it’s true that chicks dig the long ball, Davis should be having no problems getting a date these days. His 53 HRs in 2013 led the league (and it wasn’t close), but can Davis continue his power surge? Joey Votto’s reliable production gives owners the ability to put the position on auto-pilot and watch the stats pile up. In a bit of a surprise, not one voter selected Albert Pujols as their top first baseman.

 

2B Rankings

Despite ditching the bright lights of Broadway for a light drizzle atop the Space Needle, Robinson Cano still topped the charts of our 2B rankings. Cano’s move from hitter-friendly Yankee Stadium to pitcher-friendly Safeco Field might mean fewer extra base hits than usual, but Cano’s all-around game is good enough to translate to any ballpark in the world.

Other options at the position include Boston’s Dustin Pedroia and St. Louis upstart Matt Carpenter. It’s a testament to the impressive depth at the 2B position that guys like Ian Kinsler and Ben Zobrist didn’t show up on our list.

 

SS Rankings

This looks to be the final year that fantasy baseball players have the opportunity to draft Derek Jeter, but there’s no time for nostalgia. There are too many other good options out there. Colorado SS Troy Tulowitzki topped the list, but his health should be a concern for anyone spending a 1st rounder on him. Only once in the past 4 seasons has Tulo suited up for more than 130 games.

Hanley Ramirez has similar durability concerns, but when he’s on the field few shortstops offer more value. Youngsters to receive votes like Starlin Castro, Xander Bogaerts, and Jean Segura are all hoping to usher in a new era at the position.

 

Don’t forget to deposit on FanDuel using the exclusive promo code MLBPREVIEW14. We’ll match 100% of your deposit up to $200!

 

3B Rankings

Hey Miggy, you’re so fine, you’re so fine you….sorry. We got a bit carried away there. But seriously, Miguel Cabrera is worth getting carried away over. The back-to-back AL MVP is a triple crown threat again in 2014, and he’ll likely be off the board in your fantasy baseball draft before you finish your first beer. Position eligibility is a story for Cabrera as well in 2014, as both him and Detroit have expressed a desire for him to play 1B and allow Detroit’s top prospect Nick Castellanos more playing time at 3B.

Big names are abundant at the hot corner position, as guys like Evan Longoria, Adrian Beltre, and Manny Machado all received votes and offer great value at the position.

 

Outfield Rankings

 If you’re lucky enough to have the first-overall draft pick in your fantasy baseball draft, congrats on having Mike Trout on your team. He was the only unanimous choice across our survey, and for good reason. Trout has the ability to produce across five categories like no other player in baseball, and the scary part is he’s still improving—He’s only 22 years old!

2013 NL MVP Andrew McCutchen was the second most-voted for position player behind Trout, and he earned that distinction with a fantastic 2013 campaign that culminated with Pittsburgh’s first playoff berth since Barry Bonds looked like this. Even though it feels like McCutchen has been doing this for years, he’s only 27 years old and still in the prime of his career.

Other top options varied greatly, but guys like Bryce Harper and the Carlos’ (Gomez and Gonzalez) were favorites. Outfield contained the greatest variance of any position with 11 players receiving votes (Yasiel Puig received 3 votes, while Jason Heyward, Jacoby Ellsbury, and Matt Holliday all received one).

 

Relief Pitcher Rankings

FanDuel players never have to worry about the variance involved with relief pitchers, but for those of you who have resisted converting (we don’t bite, we promise!) we included them in our survey. Atlanta’s young door-closer Craig Kimbrel has taken up Mariano Rivera’s throne as the top closer in fantasy baseball. Kimbrel has the advantage of playing on a team that should win a lot of games, and people simply don’t score runs against him (from May 9 to September 10th, Kimbrel had a mind-boggling 0.19 ERA).

Boston’s Koji Uehara will hope to keep Father Time at bay for at least one more season (he’ll be 39 in April), while Glen Perkins hopes to be back in time for Opening Day after offseason knee surgery. Voting after the top guys was essentially a coin-flip between Joe Nathan and Aroldis Chapman.

 

Starting Pitcher Rankings

No matter what format you’re playing, starting pitching is always tough to gauge. Unless you have Clayton Kershaw, that is. The L.A. Dodgers ace ranks right there with Mike Trout and Miguel Cabrera as the top players in fantasy baseball, an especially impressive stat considering his position. Kershaw’s sure-fire status as the best pitcher in baseball was reflected in our voting, as only one other player received multiple votes.

That player was Texas’ Yu Darvish. “Whirling” Darvish improved mightily in his 2nd MLB season, and proved worth the unholy amounts of money that Texas paid to sign him. Justin Verlander, David Price, and Felix Hernandez (all one vote each) were the only other players to receive votes.

And there you have it! Good luck locking up the best players in your 2014 fantasy baseball draft. And hey, whenever you get sick of that team, you can come make a brand new one every single day here on FanDuel. Don’t forget to sign up with the MLBPREVIEW14 promo code and get your 100% deposit match bonus!

Survey Results

Website Catcher 1B 2B 3B SS OF OF OF SP RP
i70 Baseball Posey Cabrera Cano Beltre Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
Draft America Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw K. Uehara
BrokeMets Posey Goldschmidt M. Carpenter Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
NY Mets Life Posey Cabrera Cano Longoria Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Braun Kershaw Kimbrel
Advanced Fantasy Baseball Mauer Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen C. Gomez Kershaw Nathan
Seattle Mariners Musings Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera J. Segura Trout McCutchen Holliday Kershaw Kimbrel
Around Citi Posey Votto Pedroia Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Harper Kershaw Kimbrel
Cheap Seats Please Mauer Cabrera Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Ellsbury Kershaw Kimbrel
Fantasy Baseball Crackerjacks Mauer Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera J. Segura Trout McCutchen Harper Kershaw Kimbrel
Red Sox Nation Alberta Posey Votto Pedroia Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout C. Gonzalez Harper Kershaw K. Uehara
SeamHeads Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen A. Jones Kershaw Kimbrel
Mets Chronicle Molina Davis Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gomez Kershaw Kimbrel
Owen O’Brien (FanDuel Insider) Posey Davis Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Braun Darvish Kimbrel
Reading Between the Seams Santana Votto Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen Harper Kershaw A. Chapman
500 Level Fan Molina Goldschmidt Pedroia Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
Buzz on Broad Posey Votto Pedroia Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
Detroit Tiger Tales Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Harper Darvish A. Chapman
Matthew Musico Molina Goldschmidt Pedroia Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout A. Jones C. Gomez Kershaw Kimbrel
Off the Bench Baseball Posey Cabrera Cano Machado Tulowitzki Trout C. Gonzalez McCutchen Kershaw rosenthal
Red Legs Review Molina Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Harper Kershaw Kimbrel
SF Giants Baseball Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
Through the Fence Baseball McCann Votto Cano Zimmerman Simmons Trout Braun Heyward Verlander Kimbrel
The Best Sports Blog Mauer Davis Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout Braun McCutchen Kershaw Kimbrel
Sox Addict Posey Davis Cano Beltre H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Holland
Fenway Nation Posey Goldschmidt Pedroia Machado Bogaerts Trout Harper C. Gonzalez Kershaw K. Uehara
Tenth Inning Stretch Molina Mauer Cano Longoria Hardy Trout McCutchen C. Gomez Kershaw Perkins
More Hard Ball Posey Goldschmidt Kipnis Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen C. Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel
Fantasy Six Pack Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout C. Gonzalez McCutchen Kershaw Kimbrel
Diamond Hoggers Molina Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout Harper Puig Kershaw Kimbrel
Call to the Pen Castro Goldschmidt Pedroia Machado Tulowitzki Trout Harper Puig Price Kimbrel
Philip Oliveri (FanDuel Insider) Posey Goldschmidt Cano Cabrera Tulowitzki Trout McCutchen Harper Kershaw Kimbrel
Blood Sox Posey Davis Cano Cabrera H. Ramirez Trout McCutchen Puig F. Hernandez K. Uehara

FanDuel’s MLB 2014 Preview Series

Part 1- Fantasy Baseball Player Rankings

Part 2- Fantasy Baseball Draft Strategy

Part 3- Fantasy Baseball Busts

Part 4- Fantasy Baseball Sleepers
 
Part 5- Surprise MLB Teams
 
Part 6- Fantasy Baseball Bounce Back Players
 
Part 7- Fantasy Baseball Breakout Players
 
Part 8- World Series Predictions

**Exclusive Special**Sign up today with the promo code MLBPREVIEW14 and we’ll match your first deposit 100% up to $200. Sign up today!

 

Embed This Image On Your Site (copy code below):

Posted 1 year ago on · Permalink

About FanDuel

FanDuel is the market leader in one-day fantasy sports leagues. Play for real money against other people with immediate cash payouts. Up to $1M cash paid out every day.

Read more

How to get started

  1. Signup & use promo code INSIDER100
  2. Choose a one-day contest
  3. Pick any players you want - Salary cap format
  4. Win your league, and win real money
Get Started